Data-Driven Decisions: The Importance of Accurate Voter Lists

In modern political campaigns, data reigns supreme. The difference between winning and losing often comes down to having current, precise voter information that drives strategic decisions.

Accurate voter lists aren't just a nice-to-have - they're the foundation of effective campaigns. Here's why voter data matters and how to leverage it for success.

Why Voter Lists Matter

The Foundation of Everything

Your voter list determines:

Who you contact:

• Which voters receive your messages
• How you segment and target
• Where you allocate resources

How you message:

• Personalization elements
• Issue priorities
• Tone and approach

Where you campaign:

• Geographic targeting
• Precinct prioritization
• Event locations

When you engage:

• Timing of voter contact
• Early voting vs. Election Day focus

Poor data = poor decisions. Quality data = winning strategies.

The Cost of Bad Data

Wasted money:

• Contacting wrong phone numbers (bounced messages)
• Reaching people outside your district (can't vote for you)
• Messaging deceased voters (bad optics)
• Targeting decided opponents (zero persuasion chance)

Missed opportunities:

• Failing to reach persuadable voters
• Missing high-propensity supporters
• Overlooking key demographic groups
• Incomplete coverage of winnable precincts

Damaged reputation:

• Contacting opt-outs (legal issues)
• Wrong voter information (shows incompetence)
• Irrelevant messaging (annoys voters)

Real example: A campaign spent $15,000 texting voters, only to discover 30% of phone numbers were wrong or outdated. That's $4,500 wasted immediately.

What Makes a Quality Voter List

Essential Data Fields

Voter identification:

• Full legal name
• Voter ID number
• Registration status

Contact information:

• Residential address
• Mailing address (if different)
• Phone numbers (landline and mobile)
• Email address

Demographics:

• Age / date of birth
• Gender
• Race/ethnicity (where available)

Geographic data:

• District / precinct
• Ward
• County
• State house/senate districts
• Congressional district

Voting history:

• Elections voted in (last 2-4 cycles)
• Primary vs. general participation
• Early voting vs. Election Day
• Vote-by-mail usage

Political data:

• Party registration
• Modeled partisan score
• Turnout propensity score
• Issue interest scores (if available)

Data Quality Indicators

Accuracy:

• Information is correct
• Recently updated
• Verified against official sources

Completeness:

• Few missing fields
• Phone number match rates above 60%
• Email addresses where available

Currency:

• Updated monthly or quarterly
• Reflects recent changes
• Post-election updates

Coverage:

• Includes all registered voters in your district
• No systematic gaps
• Represents full voter universe

Where to Get Voter Lists

State Voter Files

Primary source: Your state's Secretary of State or Board of Elections

What you get:

• Official registration records
• Voting history
• Basic demographics
• Contact information (varies by state)

Cost: $25-$500+ depending on state

Pros:

• Most accurate for registration status
• Official source
• Updated regularly

Cons:

• Format varies by state
• May lack phone numbers/emails
• Can be difficult to work with

Commercial Voter Data Vendors

Major providers:

• NGP VAN (Democrats)
• i360 (Republicans)
• TargetSmart
• L2
• Aristotle

What you get:

• Enhanced voter files
• Phone number appending
• Email addresses
• Modeled scores (turnout propensity, partisanship)
• Issue interest modeling
• Consumer data overlays

Cost: $0.01-0.05 per record, or subscription fees

Pros:

• Higher phone number match rates (70-80%+)
• Additional modeling and scores
• User-friendly formats
• Regular updates

Cons:

• Costs money
• May include inaccurate modeled data
• Vendor lock-in

Party Committees

Sources:

• State party
• County party
• National committees (DCCC, NRCC, DNC, RNC)

What you get:

• Enhanced voter files
• Voter ID data (past canvassing results)
• Access to VAN/i360
• Coordinated campaigns

Cost: Often free or low-cost for aligned candidates

Pros:

• Shared infrastructure
• Historical campaign data
• Training and support

Cons:

• Only for party candidates
• May have strings attached
• Shared with other campaigns

Building Your Voter List

Step 1: Acquire Base File

Start with:

• State voter file, OR
• Commercial enhanced file, OR
• Party-provided file

Choose based on:

• Budget
• Technical capacity
• Need for enhancements

Step 2: Append Contact Information

If your base file lacks phone numbers/emails:

Phone appending:

• Commercial services ($0.02-0.05 per lookup)
• Match rates: 60-80%
• Get both landline and mobile

Email appending:

• Commercial services ($0.02-0.05 per lookup)
• Match rates: 30-50%
• Lower accuracy than phones

Consider cost vs. benefit:

• Texting requires mobile numbers
• Email campaigns need email addresses
• Door knocking only needs addresses

Step 3: Enhance with Modeling

Turnout propensity scores:

• Predict likelihood to vote
• Based on voting history
• 0-100 scale

Why it matters: Focus resources on high-propensity voters

Partisan scores:

• Predict party support
• Based on demographics, voting history, geography
• Helps identify persuadables

Why it matters: Don't waste time on committed opponents

Issue interest scores:

• Predict issue priorities
• Based on demographics and consumer data

Why it matters: Target messaging by interest

Step 4: Clean and Standardize

Address standardization:

• USPS format
• Consistent abbreviations
• Geocoding for mapping

Phone number formatting:

• Standard 10-digit format
• Remove invalid numbers
• Flag landline vs. mobile

Deduplication:

• Remove duplicate records
• Merge multiple addresses for same voter
• Identify moved voters

Verification:

• Cross-check against NCOA (National Change of Address)
• Validate phone numbers
• Update based on returned mail

Maintaining Your Voter List

Regular Updates

Monthly:

• New voter registrations
• Address changes
• Party changes

Post-election:

• Voting history updates
• Turnout propensity recalculation
• Model updates

Ongoing:

• Opt-out management
• Response tracking
• Engagement history

Adding Campaign Data

Voter ID results:

• Support level from canvassing
• Issue priorities
• Volunteer interest

Response data:

• Who responded to texts/calls
• Positive vs. negative responses
• Engagement level

Attendance:

• Event RSVPs and attendance
• Volunteer participation
• Donor status

Data Hygiene

Remove:

• Deceased voters
• Moved out of district
• Duplicate records
• Invalid contact information

Update:

• New phone numbers
• Address changes
• Party registration changes

Suppress:

• Opt-outs (legal requirement)
• Do not contact requests
• Known opponents (optional but efficient)

Using Your Voter List Strategically

Segmentation for Targeting

By turnout propensity:

• High (80-100): Light touch, turnout reminders
• Medium (50-79): Persuasion + turnout
• Low (1-49): Extensive persuasion, assistance

By partisan support:

• Strong supporters: Mobilization, volunteer recruitment
• Lean supporters: Persuasion, motivation
• Persuadables: Heavy persuasion focus
• Lean opposition: Ignore or very light persuasion
• Strong opposition: Ignore

By demographics:

• Age cohorts (different messaging)
• Gender
• Race/ethnicity
• Geography (urban/suburban/rural)

By issue interests:

• Education voters: School funding messages
• Healthcare voters: ACA protection messages
• Environment voters: Climate action messages

Resource Allocation

Where to invest:

Highest ROI:

• High-propensity persuadables (vote likely, undecided)
• Medium-propensity supporters (need motivation to vote)

Medium ROI:

• Low-propensity strong supporters (if you have resources)
• High-propensity leans (some persuasion needed)

Low ROI:

• Committed opponents
• Very low-propensity voters
• Out-of-district contacts

Personalization

Use data for personalization:

Basic:

Hi [FirstName]!

Location:

Hi [FirstName]! Your polling place is [PollingLocation]

Voting history:

Hi [FirstName]! Thank you for voting in every election since [Year]

Demographics:

Hi [FirstName]! As a [Occupation/Age Group], you know...

Issue interest:

Hi [FirstName]! Your top issue, [Issue], is on the ballot...

Common Voter List Mistakes

1. Using Outdated Data

❌ Mistake: Using 2-year-old voter file

Impact: Wrong addresses, disconnected phone numbers, deceased voters

• ✅ Fix: Update at least quarterly, ideally monthly

2. Not Cleaning Data

❌ Mistake: Never removing bad phone numbers or addresses

Impact: Wasted money on bounced messages

• ✅ Fix: Regular data hygiene, remove bounces immediately

3. Ignoring Opt-Outs

❌ Mistake: Not maintaining suppression list

Impact: Legal violations, voter anger, reputation damage

• ✅ Fix: Instant opt-out processing, maintain suppression list

4. Poor Segmentation

❌ Mistake: Treating all voters the same

Impact: Wasted resources on wrong targets, poor ROI

• ✅ Fix: Strategic segmentation by propensity and support

5. No Contact History

❌ Mistake: Not tracking who you've already contacted

Impact: Over-messaging some voters, missing others

• ✅ Fix: Log all contact attempts, track responses

6. Incomplete Data

❌ Mistake: Missing phone numbers for mobile outreach

Impact: Can't execute texting program

• ✅ Fix: Append contact data or use enhanced files

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Data Privacy

Respect voter privacy:

• Don't sell or share voter data
• Secure storage
• Limited access
• Proper disposal post-campaign

Comply with regulations:

• TCPA for texting/calling
• State privacy laws
• Campaign finance disclosure

Accuracy Obligations

Ensure accuracy:

• Don't intentionally use wrong information
• Update when voters report changes
• Remove deceased voters promptly

Avoid discrimination:

• Don't exclude voters based on protected characteristics
• Ensure equal access to campaign
• Fair targeting practices

Tools for Managing Voter Lists

What you need:

Database/CRM:

• Store and organize voter data
• Segment and filter
• Track contact history
• Export for outreach

Options:

• NGP VAN (Democrats)
• i360 (Republicans)
• Custom databases
• Spreadsheets (for very small campaigns)

Integration:

• Texting platform integration (like Political Comms)
• Email platform sync
• Canvassing app connectivity

Political Comms integrates seamlessly with major voter file platforms and accepts standard voter file formats.

The Bottom Line

Accurate voter lists are the foundation of successful campaigns:

Why they matter:

• ✅ Enable strategic targeting
• ✅ Maximize resource efficiency
• ✅ Improve personalization
• ✅ Drive better results

Quality indicators:

• ✅ Current and updated
• ✅ Accurate and verified
• ✅ Complete (high match rates)
• ✅ Enhanced with scores and modeling

Best practices:

• ✅ Start with quality source
• ✅ Enhance with appended data
• ✅ Maintain with regular updates
• ✅ Clean and verify continuously
• ✅ Use strategically for targeting
• ✅ Respect privacy and legal requirements

Remember: Your voter list is only as good as your data hygiene and strategic use. Invest in quality data and maintain it rigorously.

At Political Comms, we make it easy to import, segment, and use your voter lists for effective text outreach.

---

Ready to leverage your voter data? Get started with Political Comms.

Need help with voter file strategy? Contact our team for expert guidance.